| Order | President | Years |
|---|---|---|
| First | Richard Thatcher | 1891-1893 |
| Second | George W. Winans | 1893-1894 |
| Third | Edward Ralston "E.R." Williams | 1894-1895 |
| Fourth | Edmund Dandridge Murdaugh | 1895-1901 |
| Fifth | Frederick Howard Umholtz | 1901-1906 |
| Sixth | Thomas Walter Butcher | 1906-1908 |
| Seventh | James Argyle McLauchlin | 1908-1911 |
| Eighth | Charles Evans | 1911-1916 |
| Ninth | Grant Bartholomew Grumbine | 1916-1917 |
| Tenth | James W. Graves | 1917-1919 |
| Eleventh | John Gordon Mitchell | 1919-1931 |
| Twelfth | Malcom A. Beeson | 1931-1935 |
| Acting President | Cliff R. Otto | 1935-1935 |
| Thirteenth | John Ohlyer Moseley | 1935-1939 |
| Fourteenth | Roscoe R. Robinson | 1939-1948 |
| Acting President | George P. Huckaby | 1948-1948 |
| Fifteenth | Dr. W. Max Chambers | 1949-1960 |
| Sixteenth | Dr. Garland Alonzo Godfrey | 1960-1975 |
| Seventeenth | Dr. Bill Lillard | 1975-1992 |
| Eighteenth | George Nigh | 1992-1997 |
| Nineteenth | W. Roger Webb | 1997-2011 |
| Twentieth | Dr. Don Betz | 2011-2019 |
| Twenty-first | Patti Neuhold-Ravikumar | 2019-2023 |
| Twenty-second | Todd G. Lamb | 2023-present |
