Skip to Main Content
UCO Chambers Library logo

Research Basics

Scholarly vs. Popular

No matter what citation style you use, sometimes professors will ask you to use "scholarly articles" rather than popular magazines. Use the table below to learn what the differences are.

Still not sure if your source is peer-reviewed or not?  Try Ulrich's Periodical Directory -- it lists each periodical as Consumer, Trade, or Academic/Scholarly.

Characteristic Scholarly Journal Popular Magazine
Appearance Sober and serious
May contain graphs or charts
Will not find glossy pages or photographs
Attractive appearance
Advertisements
Heavily Illustrated
Glossy paper
Audience Scholars and students General public
Authors Scholars in the field of study Sources not cited or cited informally
Purpose Report results of original research or experimentation Provide general information
Article Acceptance Procedure Many (but not all*) scholarly journals are "refereed" or "peer reviewed" - articles undergo a rigorous examination by other scholars in the field before being published Written by hired reporters, edited by magazine editors, then published
Example Journals Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Journal of Sports Medicine
Internal Journal of Sport Psychology
Sports Illustrated
Coach and Athletic Director
Bicycling
Example Articles The use of herbal and other non-vitamin, non-mineral supplements among pre- and post-menopausal women in Ontario 10 Supplements for Women of Any Age

*All peer-reviewed journals are scholarly, but not all scholarly journals are peer-reviewed.
Peer-reviewed = reviewed by professionals in the field, independent of the journal.
Scholarly = has an editorial staff knowledgeable in the field.

Primary & Secondary Sources

What is a Primary Source?

Primary sources are original sources created by a participant or observer of a historical event that provide direct evidence or first-hand testimony. These records allow historians to study unfiltered evidence and critically develop an interpretation of the past.

Examples:

  • First-hand accounts - speeches, interviews, diaries, autobiographies
  • Accounts or first recorders of an event - newspapers, magazines, journal articles, books and pamphlets written and published during a particular time period.
  • Government documents - documents produced by government agencies, treaties, census records, maps, patents, etc.
  • Ephemera - brochures, pamphlets, posters, advertisements, etc.
  • Creative works produced at the time

Secondary and Tertiary Sources

Secondary sources are interpretations or analyses of primary sources. An example would be an article about women leaders during the civil rights movement, or a book about the Louisiana Purchase.

Tertiary sources are even further removed from the primary source. They are works that use secondary sources for information. Encyclopedias are examples of tertiary sources.

What Do You Need?

After finding some preliminary background information, think about what sources would serve your research need.

  • What documents would have been created during this event? (Newspaper articles, diaries, government documents, etc.)
  • What kind of information are you seeking? Are you looking at laws and policy where public information would be important, or are you looking at the topic from the perspective of a participant?
  • There will be multiple participants and interpretations of any event. From which perspective or lens do you want to direct your research?

Search Terms

Use Central Search to combine the keywords of your topic with these terms: ex. "George Washington" AND correspondence

  • Correspondence
  • Diaries
  • Historiography
  • Interviews
  • Papers
  • Personal Narratives
  • Sources

More Tips

You can also search specific library databases for primary sources related to your topic. Newspaper databases are good places to look.

Check the bibliography of any secondary source you find to see if they list primary sources.